Key Takeaway: Sprayers can apply paint quicker than rollers and leave a better finish quality on some surfaces. Rollers are extremely versatile tools that offer many advantages over sprayers.
I often hear questions about spray painting vs roller painting and which is better when it comes to interior painting. From my experience, sprayers are incredibly fast and efficient, but they have limitations. In this guide, I’ll walk you through the pros and cons of each method and share my insights on key factors like speed, preparation, finish quality, health and safety, and waste.
Spray Painting Vs Roller Painting - What are the Differences?
When deciding between spray painting vs roller painting, understanding the key differences can help you choose the right method for your project. From preparation and speed to finish quality and waste, each approach offers unique advantages and challenges.
Speed: Sprayer vs Roller
When comparing paint sprayers vs rollers, sprayers aren’t always faster than rollers for small projects.
Small projects and surfaces can be painted faster with a roller when you factor in the masking, setup, and clean-up of a sprayer. Sometimes, a whole room can be painted faster with a roller than with a sprayer.
In contrast, sprayers excel at covering large areas quickly, like new construction interiors or ceilings in unoccupied homes, because there is little to no prep.
We can easily apply over 50 gallons a day while spraying.
Using a roller, it’s difficult to apply more than 15, even on new construction.
No one can roll faster than even a modest airless sprayer.
Our largest airless sprayers can run two guns simultaneously with a maximum flow rate of 1.1 gallons per minute!
Preparation: Rollers Are Simpler to Set Up
One of the significant differences between a paint sprayer and a roller for interior painting services is the preparation involved. Using sprayers often requires additional preparation compared to roller painting.
A roller can easily be set up in under a minute. Simply pour the paint into the tray and put down your drop sheets.
Because sprayers are prone to overspray we often have to mask off anything that we don’t want paint on.
Sometimes, it’s not worth the extra effort to cover the surrounding surfaces.
Masking can take days on some jobs.
We often spray ceilings because we can mask off around 1500 SQFT in under 4 hours.
Once everything is covered, spraying can take as little as 30 minutes. With a late lunch break, a team of two or three painters can paint two coats on 1500 SQFT of ceilings in under a day.
Read Also: Is Priming Walls Necessary?
Finish Quality and Paint Coverage Spray vs Roller
The paint sprayer finish vs roller comparison depends on the surface. Sprayers can leave a better finish than a brush and roller on smooth surfaces.
Trim, doors and cabinets often look sharp when sprayed.
Using a brush and roller can leave undesirable texture if applied too heavily or on a smooth surface like a shaker-style door (flat and rectangular style/profile).
Rollers are sometimes better for rough surfaces because they can work the paint into uneven surfaces better than a sprayer that forces a fan in one direction.
For example, texture ceilings look much better when the paint is either applied with a roller or “back rolled” immediately after having been sprayed.
Backing rolling is a common technique that uses thick roller sleeves (15-25mil or ⅝ inches - 1-inch nap) to spread the paint and work it into rough surfaces.
We often try to cross-hatch (paint in opposing directions) between coats when using a sprayer, especially when painting ceilings. This helps to work the paint into rough surfaces so there are no holidays (areas that are missed).
We sometimes use HVLP sprayers when we paint surfaces that require a fine finish and high detail. HVLP sprayers are similar to automotive finishing equipment and offer the best finish quality available. These machines are only appropriate for finishing furniture, cabinets and other detailed projects.
Typically, the pressure pots on HVLP machines only store a litre of paint.
Health and Safety: Considerations for Sprayers
Rollers don’t require any PPE unless the coating has special safety procedures and considerations. On the other hand, using paint sprayers comes with health and safety risks. They create very fine dust that can be harmful when inhaled.
Clients and other trades working in the area may be at risk if exposed to overspray.
Products that are zero VOC (volatile organic compound) are still harmful if inhaled as excess overspray/dust from the sprayer.
Unless we’re the only trades on site, we cannot always use sprayers.
Air quality can be affected for over an hour if ventilation is poor, especially in interiors that are masked from floor to ceiling.
Waste: Sprayers vs Rollers
When evaluating painting with a spray gun vs roller, waste is an important consideration. Using sprayers creates a lot of waste that most people don’t consider. Rollers can be nearly zero waste if you clean your sleeves and reuse liners.
Sprayers need to be thoroughly cleaned after each use. This process often wastes a considerable amount of paint.
It takes around a litre of paint just to fill a 50-foot hose and prime the machine.
There is often a considerable amount of masking supplies that get used and disposed of each time we use sprayers.
Masking paper, painter's plastic, tape and other disposable materials are essential for avoiding unwanted overspray on furniture, appliances and other surfaces.
Painting a large ceiling can create two or three large garbage bags worth of wasted masking supplies that cannot be reused.
Anyone who is looking to reduce their environmental footprint and waste needs to weigh the speed and excess waste when considering sprayers carefully.
That is not to say that roller painting creates no waste– it certainly does as we still have to cover walls, furniture and appliances when painting ceilings with rollers.
We don’t have to be anywhere near as careful, and we can reuse plastic that has been used with a roller.
Paint Sprayer vs Roller: Which Method Is Better?
Typically, a paint roller is the better choice for its simplicity and effectiveness. During each interior painting project estimate, I evaluate the project’s unique needs to determine whether painting with a roller or sprayer is more appropriate.
At Seriously Painting, we provide expert interior painting services in Nanaimo, ensuring a flawless finish tailored to your project. Contact us today for a professional consultation.
Conclusion
By understanding the advantages and disadvantages of spray painting, you’ll be able to make an informed decision that suits your interior painting goals. Whether it’s about speed, finish, or waste, both tools have their place depending on the project’s requirements.
Common Questions About Spray Painting vs Roller Painting
Do professional house painters prefer painting with roller or sprayer?
Yes, it depends on the project. Sprayers are common for large areas or smooth finishes, while rollers are better for smaller projects and rough surfaces.
What are the disadvantages of spray painting?
Spray painting requires extensive preparation, creates more waste, and may pose health risks due to overspray.
When to use a paint sprayer vs roller?
Use a paint sprayer for large, smooth surfaces or when speed is essential. Opt for a roller for textured surfaces or smaller areas.
Comments